Its aims are right. What it lacks is the staff to deliver them, an honest account of what they cost, and a way of reaching hospitals whose problems differ.
£8bn unspent
1. Staff, not money, is the limit
On the evidence so far, 21,500 nursing posts are unfilled by 2035/36 and £8.1bn of that year's budget goes unspent because the staff to spend it on do not exist. The plan names no extra nursing or medical school places, and its workforce plan is unpublished.
22% vs 10%
2. The overseas target and the waiting-time target clash
On the plan's own assumptions, holding waiting times needs about 22% of joiners from overseas in 2035/36; the plan aims for under 10%. Held to its 10% path, about 17,000 posts go unfilled. Today the share is 33%.
Why the NHS needs more staff, and where it runs short
NHS trusts already have 28% more staff than in 2018/19, so why more? On the evidence so far (the likely outcome), for three reasons:
More care to give. An older population needs more hospital care. By 2035/36 there are 8% more emergency admissions than in 2025/26 (7.05 million against 6.54 million) and 9% more A&E attendances (29.4 million against 27.0 million). Bringing waiting times back to 92% needs about 12% more planned treatment on top.
Leavers to replace. About 134,000 full-time equivalent staff leave NHS trusts each year. Training in the UK supplies about 106,000 joiners. The difference, about 28,000 a year, comes from overseas just to stand still.
Productivity covers only part of it. The figures already assume staff achieve 1% more each year, as the Office for National Statistics has measured, while the care each treatment needs keeps rising slowly, as it has since 2022/23. With no productivity growth the nursing shortfall would be about twice as large.
Staff in NHS trusts, England, likely outcome (full-time equivalent)
In post 2025/26
Needed 2035/36
In post 2035/36
Short 2035/36
Nurses
367,500
418,400
396,900
21,500
Scientific, therapeutic and technical staff
179,000
203,800
195,700
8,100
Doctors
151,100
172,200
172,200
0
Midwives
25,200
28,700
28,700
0
Support to clinical staff
408,100
464,600
464,600
0
Ambulance staff
22,500
25,600
25,600
0
Infrastructure support (managers, central functions, estates)
201,000
188,300
188,300
0
All staff
1,354,400
1,501,600
1,472,000
29,600
"Needed" is the staff the care delivered requires at the productivity assumed; "short" is needed less in post. Infrastructure support falls because administration is assumed to become more productive too, and part of the planned cuts to the centre are made.
Nurses run out first. Each year about 30,300 leave; UK training supplies about 21,900 and overseas recruitment, held at about today's level, about 11,300. That grows the nursing workforce by about 2,900 a year, against about 5,100 a year needed. Scientific, therapeutic and technical staff (such as radiographers, physiotherapists and pharmacists) fall short for the same reason. Doctors keep pace until about 2040, because of the specialty training posts agreed in June 2026 and continued recruitment from overseas; by 2045/46, 61,300 nursing and 6,300 doctor posts are unfilled.
Staff a year, 2028/29
Leave
Join, UK
Join, overseas
Growth
Growth needed
Nurses
30,300
21,900
11,300
+2,900
+5,100
Scientific, therapeutic and technical staff
16,000
14,000
3,700
+1,700
+2,500
Doctors
20,900
15,100
8,100
+2,200
+2,100
Support to clinical staff
43,400
35,600
13,700
+6,000
+5,700
All staff
133,700
105,700
40,200
+12,200
+14,700
Likely outcome, full-time equivalent staff in NHS trusts in 2028/29. Join, UK: joiners from UK training; join, overseas: recruits from overseas, held at about today's level. Growth = joiners less leavers. Growth needed: the average a year from 2025/26 to 2035/36 to keep up with the staff needed. All staff includes midwives, ambulance and infrastructure staff, not shown separately. Where growth falls short of what is needed, the gap builds up year by year into the shortfalls above.
Even the plan as claimed runs short. Because it assumes 2% productivity a year, it needs almost no more staff than today. But cutting overseas recruitment to 10% of joiners means fewer join than leave: nurses in post fall from 367,500 to 358,300 by 2035/36 and doctors from 151,100 to 146,900, leaving about 17,000 posts unfilled (11,600 nurses and 5,300 doctors).
Source: the report's simulation, from NHS Workforce Statistics (staff, joiners and leavers by nationality, NHS trusts) and published training numbers. Nationality stands in for overseas recruitment.
2% vs 1%
3. The sums rest on productivity double what has been measured
The plan assumes 2% a year; the Office for National Statistics measured 1.1% in 2024 and 1.0% in 2025. The difference is the difference between 83% and 53% of patients waiting under 18 weeks in 2035/36. NHS England also plans on pay rises of 2.1% a year; the 2026/27 awards were 3.3%, and 3.5% for doctors.
After 2029
4. No money after 2028/29, and the buildings keep decaying
The plan sets no budget beyond the Spending Review. On its capital funding, the maintenance backlog grows from £15.9bn to about £21bn by 2035/36.
3 in 4
5. A&E is a problem inside departments
Three in four four-hour breaches happen before any wait for a bed. Even a 90% cut in delayed discharges lifts the four-hour measure by only about 0.6 points. Nothing in the plan, or tested here, closes the gap to 82% and 85%.
117 hospitals
6. One national plan meets very different hospitals
The fullest hospitals, those with the most delayed discharges and those with the worst A&E are largely different trusts, so a national lever spread evenly lands mostly where it is not the problem. And the plan gives freedom to trusts doing well, and more central control and less money to those with the hardest problems.
England's 117 acute trusts, 2025/26. Dashed lines mark the fullest 40% in winter (blue) and the 40% with most delayed patients per bed.