The NHS in England · 5 of 5
What would meet the targets?
On today's budget and the productivity actually measured, nothing tested here meets every target. One package, on the same budget, gets much closer on waiting times, and two decisions would carry it to 92%. Nothing tested gets A&E to its targets.
A better way, same budget
Train more staff, keep them longer, recruit from overseas while home training builds up, aim discharge help at the fullest hospitals, and maintain the estate. On the evidence, not the plan's hopes, that reaches 88% within 18 weeks by March 2029, holds 71% in 2035/36 against 53%, and returns to 88% by 2045/46. It does it by spending the money the plan leaves idle for lack of staff.
| What changes | Cost a year by 2035/36 | What it buys |
|---|---|---|
| Overseas recruitment as needed until home-trained staff arrive | – | No posts left empty; without it, 21 points lower by 2045/46 |
| Staff kept longer: leaver rates a tenth lower by 2028/29 | £0.18bn | 14,700 staff a year kept; 13,600 fewer overseas joiners a year |
| More training: medical school places +50%, specialty training posts doubled, nursing places +40%, GP training +20% | £1.1bn | 7,600 fewer overseas joiners a year from the early 2030s |
| Discharge help at the fullest 40% of hospitals: delayed discharges a quarter lower | £0.15bn | About 98,000 fewer A&E waits for a bed a year |
| The estate maintained: backlog cleared by March 2036, equipment and IT replaced as they wear out | £2.1bn | £21bn backlog cleared; no further decay |
Costs are paid from the same budget as the plan, at 2024/25 prices. Keeping staff is the cheapest part: where overseas recruitment is limited, a tenth fewer leavers lifts the share waiting under 18 weeks from 53% to 70% in 2035/36 for about £0.17bn a year.
What would take it to 92%
| Patients waiting under 18 weeks, March 2035/36 | The likely outcome | The better way |
|---|---|---|
| On the evidence so far (productivity 1% a year; budget 1.5% a year above inflation from 2029/30) | 53% | 71% |
| Productivity 2% a year, as the plan assumes | 83% | 92% |
| Budget 2.0% a year above inflation from 2029/30 | 53% | 91% |
| No productivity growth | 41% | 41% |
Two things decide it. Productivity first: without it nothing works, and at the plan's 2% the better way meets the target throughout. Then money after 2028/29: about 2% a year above inflation holds the gains. Extra money does nothing until the staff are there to spend it, which is why the staff come first.
Meeting 92% on the evidence as it stands needs about 13,000 more doctors by 2028/29 and 29,000 by 2035/36, medical school places doubled, nursing places up 80%, and overseas recruitment without a limit until home-trained staff arrive. The money is close: about £0.9bn a year above the budget in 2035/36. The staff are not.
A&E
No run reaches the A&E targets. About 1,700 more A&E consultants would cost £0.33bn a year, and the evidence for their effect ranges from nothing to about 2.7 points. Reaching 85% needs changes inside departments that no one has yet costed or shown to work at scale. The targets should be treated as unfunded until a route is shown, and departments improved one by one.
What should change
- Publish the workforce plan, costed, with training places and a retention target. A medical school place started now produces a consultant in the late 2030s.
- Set a retention target, and test what delivers it.
- Choose openly between the overseas target and the waiting-time target.
- Set the NHS budget beyond 2028/29.
- Plan on realistic prices and productivity, and fund the difference.
- Maintain the estate: about £2.7bn a year more capital.
- Aim discharge help at the hospitals that run fullest in winter.
- Treat the A&E targets as unfunded until a costed route is shown.
- Let support and freedom for hospitals follow need as well as performance.
Full report (PDF, 23 pages)Evidence bank (PDF)How it was done
Projections test the plan's arithmetic; they are not forecasts. See Method and limits.