The NHS in England · 3 of 5
Will the plan work?
No, not as it stands. Even taking every claim at face value, the plan misses its 92% waiting-time target, then falls back as nurses and doctors run short. On what the evidence so far supports, it does worse. A&E stays at about 75% on every run.
| Patients waiting under 18 weeks, March | 2028/29 | 2035/36 | 2045/46 |
|---|---|---|---|
| The plan as claimed: every claim taken at face value | 88% | 59% | 42% |
| The likely outcome: each claim replaced by what has been measured so far | 73% | 53% | 45% |
| The plan's target | 92% | 92% | 92% |
Against each target
| Target | The plan as claimed | The likely outcome |
|---|---|---|
| 92% within 18 weeks by March 2029 | 88% in 2028/29; 59% in 2035/36 Missed | 73% in 2028/29; 53% in 2035/36 Missed |
| A&E: 82% within 4 hours by March 2027, 85% in 2028/29 | 74.6% in 2028/29 Missed | 74.3% in 2028/29 Missed |
| Overseas recruits under 10% of joiners by 2035 | 7% Met, but about 17,000 posts unfilled in 2035/36 | About 35% needed Missed |
| Within the budget | Yes, with £20.0bn unspent in 2035/36 for lack of staff | Yes, with £8.1bn unspent in 2035/36 for lack of staff |
Why it falls back
On its own assumptions the plan gets close by 2029. After that its 10% overseas path bites: with no extra training places, 11,600 nursing and 5,300 doctor posts are unfilled by 2035/36, and £20bn of that year's budget cannot be spent because the staff to spend it on do not exist.
On the evidence, the waiting-time share peaks at 74% in 2027/28 and falls every year after. The binding limit is nursing: 21,500 posts unfilled by 2035/36.
Without any productivity growth, simply holding waiting times where they are costs more than the budget from 2030/31, £10.6bn short by 2035/36.
How it was tested
A simulation of England's seven NHS regions and 117 acute trusts to 2045/46, built from every trust's accounts and NHS England's statistics, and tested against three years it had not seen. Waiting times are its result, not an input: each year, treatment is limited by the budget, the staff in post and the target. The figures test the plan's arithmetic; they are not forecasts. See Method and limits.
Full report (PDF, 23 pages)Evidence bank (PDF)How it was done